The River Room at the Savoy Hotel has long been a sanctuary for London’s elite, a place where the light off the Thames reflects against fine crystal and even finer reputations. In 1961, it became the arena for a battle of wits that would change the course of wine history. Lily Bollinger, elegant and poised in her tailored suit, was there to present her latest vintages to the British press. Across from her sat Cyril Ray, a renowned wine critic and best-selling author known for his sharp tongue and, on this particular day, a blazer he later described as “bruised tangerine.”

Ray had arrived with a healthy dose of skepticism. He was a man who lived to challenge the established order, and the “Grand Dame” of Aÿ was the ultimate establishment figure. He came to test her, perhaps expecting a figurehead who relied more on her late husband’s title than her own technical expertise. What he found instead was a woman who knew every inch of her vineyards and every chemical reaction in her cellars. To Lily, Cyril initially seemed like a “barnacle” on the hull of her progress, but she was prepared to scrape him off with style.

Continue Reading →